AI Medical Malpractice Expert Witness: Dr. Hassan Bencheqroun, MD
Dr. Hassan Bencheqroun, MD, FCCP, EMBA, is a practicing pulmonary and critical care physician, certified by the American Board of Artificial Intelligence in Medicine, who reviews medical malpractice and medicolegal cases where artificial intelligence played a role in patient care. He accepts plaintiff and defense retention.
Who reviews AI-related medical malpractice cases in critical care and pulmonary medicine?
Most AI expert witnesses are engineers or computer scientists. Most physician expert witnesses have never configured, validated, or overridden a clinical algorithm. Dr. Bencheqroun sits in both rooms. He still manages ICU patients, in person and through TeleICU, where sepsis alerts, early warning scores, remote monitoring, and AI documentation tools are part of the shift. He also teaches clinicians how to evaluate and govern those tools through Medical AI Academy.
That combination answers the question a jury will ask: what would a reasonable intensivist have done with this AI output, on this patient, at this hour?
What kinds of AI-related cases does he review?
Following the algorithm
Harm after a clinician acted on an AI recommendation: a sepsis prediction score, a deterioration index, an AI-read chest imaging study, or a pulmonary embolism triage tool. Was reliance reasonable? Was the tool validated for this population?
Ignoring the algorithm
Harm after an AI alert was dismissed, overridden, or never seen. Alert fatigue, override documentation, and escalation pathways decide these cases.
AI scribes and ambient documentation
Notes generated by ambient AI that contain errors, omissions, or invented findings, and the physician's duty to review what goes into the chart.
TeleICU and remote monitoring
Liability when algorithmic surveillance, virtual nursing, and remote intensivists share responsibility for a deteriorating patient.
AI-triggered defensive medicine
Extra testing, extra consults, and extra documentation ordered because an algorithm said so, and whether that care met or departed from the standard.
Hospital AI governance
Whether a health system vetted, validated, trained staff on, and monitored the AI tools it put in front of clinicians.
How does AI change the standard of care?
The standard of care is still what a reasonable physician would do in similar circumstances. AI changes the circumstances. Three questions now show up in almost every case:
- Was reliance reasonable? Following an AI recommendation that departs from standard practice can expose a physician. Legal scholars have argued that, under current law, physicians are most protected when they use AI to confirm standard care rather than to replace it (Price, Cohen, and Gerke, JAMA, 2019).
- Was the tool fit for this patient? Validation population, FDA clearance status, intended use, and known performance gaps all matter.
- Who else shares responsibility? Hospitals that adopt AI without validation, training, or monitoring, and manufacturers whose tools fail as designed, are part of the liability picture. As of late 2025, physicians and hospitals still carried most of that risk (Medical Economics, October 2025).
Automation bias, where clinicians over-trust a machine's output, and alert fatigue, where they under-trust it, are both recognized patterns. An expert has to separate a reasonable judgment call from a departure from the standard.
What is AI-triggered defensive medicine?
Defensive medicine is care ordered to reduce legal risk rather than to help the patient. AI can make it worse or better. Worse, when clinicians order tests to "clear" every algorithmic alert, over-document, or refuse a useful tool for fear of being second-guessed. Better, when a well-validated tool supports a decision and leaves an audit trail showing why the physician acted. A 2025 analysis in BioLaw Journal describes these new forms of defensive behavior and argues that liability should shift toward manufacturers when highly autonomous systems fail (Natale, 2025).
Dr. Bencheqroun frames AI as a safety net that catches care gaps, not a replacement for clinical judgment. His opinions ask whether the safety net was built, checked, and used the way a careful ICU team would use it.
What records should you request in a case involving clinical AI?
- The AI tool's name, vendor, version, and FDA clearance status at the time of care
- Alert and score history with timestamps, including who viewed, acknowledged, or overrode each alert
- EHR audit logs and documented override reasons
- Drafts and final versions of AI-generated notes, if an ambient scribe was used
- The hospital's AI governance policy, validation reports, and staff training records
- TeleICU or remote monitoring logs and communication records
- Vendor instructions for use and any known limitations
Why is Dr. Bencheqroun qualified to give opinions on clinical AI?
- Triple board-certified by the American Board of Internal Medicine: Internal Medicine, Pulmonary Disease, and Critical Care Medicine
- Certified by the American Board of Artificial Intelligence in Medicine (ABAIM)
- Fellow of the American College of Chest Physicians (FCCP) and Member-at-Large, CHEST Board of Regents
- Practicing intensivist; Associate Medical Director, Vituity at Desert Regional Medical Center; Associate Director, Tele-ICU.US Inc.
- Assistant Clinical Professor, UC Riverside School of Medicine
- CEO and Founder, Medical AI Academy, and host of the AI-Ready Doctor podcast
See the full MedExpert Consulting page for engagement steps, or the full biography.
Frequently asked questions about AI in medical malpractice cases
Can a physician be liable for following an AI recommendation?
Yes, if a reasonable physician would have recognized that the recommendation was wrong for that patient. AI output does not replace clinical judgment, and courts still measure the physician against what a reasonable peer would have done.
Can a physician be liable for ignoring an AI alert?
Possibly. If the tool was validated, in routine use, and the alert pointed to a finding a careful physician would have acted on, a dismissed alert can become evidence. Documented override reasons often decide these cases.
Who is liable when an AI scribe puts an error in the medical record?
The signing clinician is generally responsible for the content of the note. Hospitals and vendors may share responsibility depending on how the tool was selected, configured, and monitored.
Does using AI increase or decrease malpractice risk?
Both are possible. Well-governed AI with a clear audit trail can support a defense. Poorly validated AI, unread alerts, or unreviewed AI notes can create new exposure.
Does Dr. Bencheqroun take plaintiff and defense AI cases?
Yes. He accepts plaintiff and defense retention after a conflict check, and offers record review, written opinions, depositions, and trial testimony, including remote depositions.
What specialties does he cover in AI-related cases?
Pulmonary medicine, critical care, ICU and TeleICU care, sepsis, respiratory failure, rapid response systems, and hospital AI governance.
Sources
- Price WN II, Cohen IG, Gerke S. Potential liability for physicians using artificial intelligence. JAMA. 2019. University of Michigan Law repository
- Littrell A. The new malpractice frontier: who's liable when AI gets it wrong? Medical Economics, October 7, 2025. Link
- Natale A. Defensive medicine in the era of artificial intelligence. BioLaw Journal, 2025. Link
- Frontiers in Medicine. Mini review on AI and medical liability, 2023. Link
Last reviewed: October 2026. This page describes expert consulting services and is not legal advice.
Discuss an AI-related case
Send party names, jurisdiction, and a short fact summary for a conflict check. Please do not send privileged records with the first inquiry.